Skip to content

The Pit of Judgment

Or, Not Being the Brother Who Is Always Right

Luke 6:37–42 Sean Higgins

Download

Jesus transitions from loving to judging. Both topics have been co-opted by non-disciples and used against disciples. Maybe there is no more misused verse by both groups than “Judge not.”

There are different and acceptable ways to distinguish between sections in Jesus’ sermon. But there is a set of four commands related to right judgment in verses 37-38, with a bookend about right judgment in verse 42. This recommends verses 37-42 as a unit about how we think about one another.

If love, the focus in the previous paragraph, depends on the subject loving and not on the object’s loveliness, then where should we start a diagnosis if love is broken? Also, whereas verses 27-36 expect Big Whoop Love, a love that spills over onto haters, it turns out that we will have a hard time treating brothers in the community very well if our hearts aren’t right. A certain kind of loving prefers self over others, and a certain kind of judging condemns others over self.

Let’s also observe that in between the bookends of judgment is a pivot about where we learn perspective. When you walk with the wise you become wise, when you walk with the judgy-pants you will also become a person who is excellent at seeing how everyone else is an idiot.

Two ways to fall into the pit of judgement: Measured Superiority and Learned Hypocrisy. Jesus’ disciples stay out of the pit and are magnanimous and merciful and learn to deal with their own sin first. Among brothers there should be love, mercy, maturity, morality, generosity, in attitude and vibe and benefit of the doubt.

Measured Superiority (verses 37-38)

The four imperatives fit a pattern of fours: four blesseds and four woes (20-26), four commands about loving haters (27-28), and four concrete cases (29-30). They also follow right after imitative mercy in verse 36. Not only does the Father not call us to do something He won’t, He calls us to be just like Him.

Judge not. Don’t be judgy. Don’t start with the attitude of a superior. Don’t start your day evaluating how everyone else around you is failing.

Condemn not. This is a step further, a conclusion of judgment that leads to exclusion.

Both of these commands are proverbial. Already Jesus judged as blessed those who are judged and condemned (verse 22), so it’s not as if we are guaranteed always to win through winsomeness. We should seek to live peaceably. “If possible, so far as it depends on you, live peaceably with all” (Romans 12:18).

But when you start the fire, don’t be surprised when others fight back with fire. You walk in throwing sucker punches, you’re the sucker if you think they are just going to turn the other cheek (even if they should).

The positive alternative to a condemning spirit is generous mercy, not indifference. If you’ve ever lived under the critical shadow, you know what to do differently.

Instead, forgive. Instead, give. Again, these are proverb-promises. Want to have friends? Don’t be the one always taking offense and holding onto it. Want to get along with others? Stop explaining why you deserve to be bitter and they deserve to know about it.

The virtue of generosity gets a lot of space; verse 38 is long. This is because generosity is one of the most divine and potent attributes on earth. Whatever else is true about the Most High, He gives. All is gift. He gives to the ungrateful. He gives to the evil. He gives to all. It was the snake’s first insinuation: you (Eve) need to take what God is too stingy to give.

We may need budgets for our giving. Stewards know their limits, and responsible adults have bills. So be it. But if the first phrases that come to mind are things like “it’s not fair” and the “they don’t deserve it” and the “what’s in it for me,” we’re likely dealing with a small soul.

Jesus says, For with the measure you use it will be measured back to you (verse 38). The illustration is grain, with the extra effort to get as much as possible in the portion. Let your measure be magnanimous. Don’t lightly stack the scoops of ice cream around the edges to leave the center hollow; pack it down.

Learned Hypocrisy (verses 39-42)

The parable is a comparison. Does the parable end in verse 39? Is it both verses 39 and 40? There is a new illustration in verses 41-42, and 39-40 don’t initially seem to belong together. What gives?

The application in verse 40 depends on the illustration in verse 39. A blind person can lead, just not well, and more than likely into big trouble. When no one can see the dangers then watch out; which is ironic, since that’s exactly what blind people can’t do. The pit is not just a drainage ditch, it’s a deep hole.

So pay attention to whom you follow. A stream usually doesn’t rise higher than its source, and a student typically doesn’t know more than his teacher. This was especially so in an environment when books weren’t easily available. Learning was necessarily 3-d. You couldn’t carry a book around to read so you had to follow a teacher around to listen, and imitate.

A fully trained student would be like his teacher…for good or bad.

Either your teacher leads you straight into a pit or points out that some teaching is straight from the pit. The teacher comment in verse 40 makes all of this a matter of discipleship and formation, not merely etiquette. You learn to be judgy and stingy, or you learn to give.

There are a lot of teachers these days, and we don’t have to be in the same zip code with them. It’s a blessing, and it also requires more attention to sources.

Anger will get you an audience, until the audience eventually turns angry with you. The University of Grievances has a worldwide membership with lots of local chapters, they just aren’t very fun. Christians have their own version with discernment bloggers and prophets of rage. We’ve produced some of the most elite judgers and condemners on the planet.

I don’t think that you have to wait until a dude is dead before you can decide it’s alright to trust them. But you should keep your eyes open.

Have they fallen into the pit of judgment? Do an audit of your favorite podcasts and follows. Do they leave you more wise and merciful or more cynical and judgmental, and isolated?

This is connected to one of the great word pictures in the Bible: the speck and the log. The relationship is between brothers (x4). The blind guide is the brother with a log who sets himself up as an eye doctor.

Speck is like a splinter of straw or chip of wood. Log is like a load-bearing beam; the kind that needs a few burly men to carry. It’s a ridiculous image, and that’s how ridiculous it is to be oblivious to one’s own issues.

A hypocrite is a morality player, a righteousness pretender. To pronounce sin in another is to act as if sin matters. But if sin is such a big problem, how did you get stuck in it? The offense is not simply possessing a fault while noticing someone else’s fault. It is posing as the competent corrector.

And it is critical to finish the point. It’s first…and then. We don’t ever want to say that small sin is acceptable. Sins are not the same size, but speck-sin is still sin. The speck is not good. Don’t abandon discernment, but don’t be the brother who is always right in his own eyes.

Conclusion

As sons of the Most High, let measured superiority be turned into generous mercy. As students of Jesus, learn to see correctly, and watch out for pretend moral superiority that often turns into learned hypocrisy. Yes, talk to the brother with the speck in his eye, but don’t be the brother everyone sees coming who is the always-knows-better-brother.

Our homes and our community should not be places Where seldom is heard an encouraging word. Start by seeing what others are good for, as in, the good signs of God’s gifting to them. Give thanks and praise and encouragement. Point out that sin isn’t just bad, sin is what keeps them from being more fruitful for good.

Churches can also learn this superior, if not also hypocritical, position. But so also can institutions grow to be more and more generous and honest.

Don’t be excellent at overstating the sin of others while being oblivious to your own. If you wonder if this is you, ask a brother, “Am I missing my beam?”

Or ask, am I using “I have my own sins” as an excuse never to help? What would “and then” require this week?

And what’s one gift you can press down?


Charge

Brothers, open your eyes to how you can forgive and give. Open your eyes about what teachers you are following and what they are training you to be. Get the beam out, and then see clearly to help your brothers also learn mercy and generosity. Let mercy triumph over judgment (James 2:13).

Benediction:

[May you be] strengthened with all power, according to his glorious might, for all endurance and patience with joy; giving thanks to the Father, who has qualified you to share in the inheritance of the saints in light. (Colossians 1:11–12 ESV)